Menu items and product availability may vary by location.

Smooth and Creamy Custard

A smooth, creamy custard with subtle hints of vanilla, baked inside our flaky pastry crust and sprinkled with nutmeg. Call your local Bakers Square to reserve your Custard pie today.


American Pie Council Award Winner:


Nutritional/Allergen Information

Pie varieties may vary by location. Pie availability may vary by season. Our pies are produced in a facility that processes milk, egg, tree nuts, wheat, peanuts and soybeans.


The American Pie Council (APC) is an organization committed to preserving America’s pie heritage and promoting America’s love affair with pies. The APC has created a standard or quality in pie making and hosts the annual National Pie Championships.