Our Pies
The Best Pie in America®
NEW! Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough A layer of chocolate chip cookie topped with our classic French Silk and garnished with real whipped cream, chocolate drizzle and chocolate chip cookie dough bites.

Order Now

Info

NEW! Red, White & Blueberry More American than Apple pie! Tart, red Michigan cherries, crisp Michigan Northern Spy Apples, and wild Maine Blueberries create this colorful red, white and blue pie. Spiced with cinnamon and baked inside a flaky, golden lattice pastry crust.

Order Now

Info

Fresh Strawberry Cream Cheese Fresh strawberry season is short, but while it lasts, we fold hand-picked California strawberries into a delicate glaze on top of New York-style cheesecake in a graham cracker crust.

Call your local Bakers Square to reserve your Fresh Strawberry Cream Cheese pie today.

Info

Key Lime Cool and refreshing, this is a summer seasonal favorite. Tangy Key limes are blended with sweetened condensed milk and eggs, baked inside a graham cracker crust, then topped with real whipped cream and a fresh slice of lime for the perfect balance of tart and sweet.

Order Now

Info

Fresh Strawberry Exclusively made during the peak of strawberry harvest. Hand-picked California strawberries are folded into a delicate strawberry glaze surrounded by a heaping portion of real whipped cream inside our flaky, award-winning pastry crust.

Call your local Bakers Square to reserve your Fresh Strawberry pie today.

Info

Banana Cream A delicious vanilla cream filling layered with fresh, ripe banana slices inside our award-winning pastry crust. Topped with real whipped cream and toasted almonds.

Order Now

Info

Blueberry Plump, refreshing wild Maine blueberries baked inside our award-winning, flaky pastry crust.

Order Now

Info

Caramel Apple à La Mode Our Country Apple Pie is transformed into a pie sundae! Sweet, crisp Michigan Northern Spy apples seasoned with Saigon cinnamon and baked inside our flaky pastry crust. Topped with rich vanilla ice cream, warm caramel sauce and pecans.

Order Now

Info

Caramel Pecan Silk Supreme A rich and decadent pie featuring a layer of our classic French Silk, a creamy supreme filling, and a layer of caramel and Texas pecans. Topped with real whipped cream and drizzled with chocolate sauce, caramel and pecans.

Order Now

Info

Carrot Cake Mouth-watering, three-layer cake with shredded carrots, pineapple, walnuts and raisins covered in frosting made with PHILADELPHIA® cream cheese, then sprinkled with chopped, toasted almonds.

Order Now

Info

Cheesecake A classic, New York-style cheesecake made with rich PHILADELPHIA® cream cheese, baked inside a graham cracker crust.

Order Now

Info

Cherry Juicy, tart Michigan red cherries inside our award-winning pastry crust.

No-Sugar-Added Cherry pie is also available. Made with NutraSweet®.

Order Now

Info

Chocolate Peanut Butter Cup Layers of our dark chocolate French Silk and chunky peanut butter cup silk inside our own, unique peanut-graham cracker crust. Topped with real whipped cream, chocolate peanut butter cups and roasted peanuts, then drizzled with chocolate ganache and caramel.

Order Now

Info

Coconut Cream A buttery vanilla cream filling blended with shredded coconut, then topped with real whipped cream and toasted coconut shavings inside our award-winning pastry crust.

Order Now

Info

Country Apple Sweet, crisp Michigan Northern Spy apples seasoned to perfection with Saigon cinnamon and covered in our flaky, award-winning pastry crust.

No-Sugar-Added Apple pie is also available. Made with NutraSweet®.

Order Now

Info

Custard A smooth, creamy custard with subtle hints of vanilla, baked inside our flaky pastry crust and sprinkled with nutmeg.

Order Now

Info

French Apple Our delicious, Country Apple filling made with crisp, sweet Michigan Northern Spy apples, lightly spiced with Saigon cinnamon and crowned with a rich butter crumb topping that is baked to perfection.

Order Now

Info

French Apple Cream Cheese A layer of our rich New York-style cheesecake topped with a layer of apple filling made with crisp Michigan Northern Spy apples and Saigon cinnamon all inside a delectable graham cracker crust. Lightly sprinkled with a sweet, butter crumb topping and finished with real whipped cream.

Order Now

Info

French Silk Our best seller! Velvety smooth chocolate silk covered with real whipped cream and milk chocolate curls, inside our award-winning pastry crust.

Order Now

Info

Harvest Pumpkin An award-winning and traditional treat made with real pumpkin custard spiced to perfection with Saigon cinnamon, ginger and nutmeg, baked inside our award-winning pastry crust.

Order Now

Info

Hot Fudge Brownie à La Mode A slice of our rich, triple-chocolate brownie pie baked with walnuts. Topped with a scoop of vanilla ice cream, drizzled with hot fudge and sprinkled with walnuts and pecans.

Order Now

Info

Lemon Meringue Whipped and baked egg whites are toasted to golden brown to make the light, fluffy meringue that sits on top of an irresistible, tangy lemon filling inside our flaky pastry crust.

Order Now

Info

Lemon Supreme Layers of tangy lemon filling and cool, creamy supreme filling inside our flaky, golden pie crust, then topped with real whipped cream.

Order Now

Info

No-Sugar-Added Cherry Juicy, tart, Michigan red cherries inside our light, flaky crust and no added sugar.

Made with NutraSweet®.

Order Now

Info

OREO® Cookie Crunch A crisp, dark chocolate OREO® cookie crust filled with sweet cookies and cream silk made with OREO® cookie pieces, bordered with real whipped cream and topped with a cherry.

Order Now

Info

Peach Sweet, sun-ripened California peaches inside our golden, flaky pastry crust. This pie is a multiple time blue ribbon winner!

Order Now

Info

Sour Cream Raisin Sour cream and plump raisins folded into a smooth, lightly spiced filling finished with real whipped cream and chopped pecans.
(Available only at Participating Restaurants)


Order Now

Info

Southern Pecan Toasted Texas pecans and a luxurious caramel filling are baked inside our golden, flaky pie crust. One of our most award winning pies!

Order Now

Info

Strawberry Rhubarb We created the perfect combination of sweet and tart with strawberries and rhubarb baked together inside our light, flaky pastry crust.

Order Now

Info

Triple Berry Tart raspberries, plump, wild Maine blueberries, and juicy Northeastern boysenberries blend together to create a pie that's bursting with flavor.

Order Now

Info

Our pies are produced in a facility that processes milk, egg, tree nuts, wheat, peanuts and soybeans.
Available all day, every day for only $7.89.
Choose any 4 different items from over 30 options.
Stop by your neighborhood Bakers Square on
Wednesdays for a FREE slice of your favorite!
A convenient way to give the great taste of
Bakers Square food and pies.